Supreme Court Examines Penal Consequences For Refusing Vande Mataram
· India · Indian Express, Times of India
The Supreme Court is examining whether refusing to sing Vande Mataram at official functions can lead to penal consequences. The petition, filed by Carnatic singer T M Krishna, argues that the mandate to sing all six stanzas violates secularism due to explicit Hindu references in the final four verses. During the hearing, the bench led by Chief Justice of India Surya Kant noted that while the song's content may not violate secularism, the issue of penalizing conscientious objectors requires legal review. The court referenced the 1986 Bijoe Emmanuel ruling, which protected students who refused to sing the National Anthem while standing in respectful silence. The hearing also featured a heated exchange between Solicitor General Tushar Mehta and a senior advocate over a remark regarding Naxalites.
Why it matters
The court's eventual ruling will clarify the legal limits of mandatory participation in national songs and the protection of individual conscience under the Constitution.
Read the original report — Indian Express
Join us on Telegram
Breaking news the moment it lands. At 10,000 members we ship the Android app.